Based on human research (Figure 1), we speculate that perceptual

Based on human research (Figure 1), we speculate that perceptual skills that rely on temporal processing

(e.g., low-frequency discrimination, FM detection, AM detection) would serve this goal. Coupled with the fact that natural sounds are composed of temporal correlations and amplitude modulations (Singh and Theunissen, 2003), it is plausible that experience-dependent plasticity plays a prominent role in the maturation of temporal processing circuits. One approach is to examine the plasticity of amplitude modulation (AM) coding. Central coding of AM is well characterized in adults of several species (Krishna and Semple, 2000, Liang et al., 2002, Joris et al., 2004, Woolley and Casseday, 2005, Wang et al., 2008 and Woolley et al., 2009), and

DAPT research buy animals, including juveniles, can be operantly conditioned to indicate when they detect AM signals (Schulze and Scheich, 1999, Sarro and Sanes, 2010 and Sarro and Sanes, 2011) or temporal gaps in continuous sounds (Wagner et al., 2003). Therefore, the behavioral relevance of experimentally induced Regorafenib cell line shifts in pattern discrimination could provide fertile ground for developmental plasticity studies. For example, exposing rat pups to FM stimuli has a differential effect on cortical physiology, depending on the age of exposure (Insanally et al., 2009). The behavioral impact remains to be determined, but the physiology results predict that the effects of FM exposure on perception will vary with the age of the experience.

Correlating early-stage changes in physiology with perceptual development is plausible given that both young and older animals exhibit some similar reflexive behaviors such as paired pulse inhibition. Habituation generalization may Tryptophan synthase also serve as a successful assay for early perceptual development. However, the fundamental challenge to identifying causal relationships between neonatal physiology and perception is that the entire system, from pinna shape to descending motor pathways, is immature. While experimental paradigms that examine early development have proven fruitful, we suggest that late-developing perceptual skills are most favorable for the purpose of identifying direct associations between neurophysiological mechanisms and behavior. Coding selectivity for the frequency modulations (FMs) inherent to many vocalizations is firmly established for midbrain, thalamus, and ACx neurons (Suga, 1965, Heil et al., 1992, Mendelson et al., 1993, Rauschecker and Tian, 2000 and Nelken and Versnel, 2000). For example, bat midbrain and ACx neurons respond selectively to downward FM sweeps that mimic their sonar calls (Pollak et al., 2011 and Fuzessery et al., 2011). This “direction selectivity” develops months after the onset of hearing in the echolocation range and the use of sonar signals, suggesting that experience plays a role in its development.

For both considered models of Figure 1, the response rises with i

For both considered models of Figure 1, the response rises with increasing

overall stimulus intensity in a sigmoid fashion (Figure 1C), as determined by the intrinsic nonlinearitities of each output neuron. Despite these similarities in the general shape of the stimulus-response relations, the characteristic differences of stimulus integration in the two models become strikingly apparent when one considers the contour lines of the stimulus-response plot, that is, the lines along which the response of the output neuron stays the same (Figures 1A and 1B, shown below the stimulus-response surface plots). The shape of these iso-response curves is a clear signature of the underlying signal integration or, in other words, of the arithmetic check details rule with which the output neuron combines its inputs.

In the simplest case, linear summation of inputs is reflected learn more by straight lines in the iso-response curves (Figure 1A). The circular part of the iso-response curves in Figure 1B, on the other hand, shows the summation of squared positive inputs, whereas the line segments that run parallel to the axes indicate the thresholding of negative inputs. Iso-response curves thus reveal the nature of stimulus integration independently of the neuron’s intrinsic output nonlinearity; the output nonlinearity simply affects the response equally for all stimuli along an iso-response curve and thus does not influence the curve’s shape. To assess the nature of signal integration within the receptive field center of retinal ganglion cells, we developed an approach to measure these iso-response curves. We used a stimulus layout that subdivided the receptive field center of a ganglion cell into two halves and stimulated the cell with different levels of light intensity in these two regions (Figure 1D). Iso-response curves then consisted Ergoloid of those pairs of

visual contrast in the two receptive field halves (measured relative to the mean background light intensity) that yielded a fixed, predefined spike response of the ganglion cell. Seeking iso-response stimuli poses an obvious experimental challenge; instead of measuring responses for predefined stimuli, we need to find stimuli for predefined neuronal responses. To achieve this, we devised a closed-loop experimental design to automatically and quickly tune stimulus intensities toward the desired response, similar to previous applications in the auditory system (Gollisch et al., 2002 and Gollisch and Herz, 2005). We recorded spiking activity extracellularly from individual ganglion cells in isolated salamander retinas. For every analyzed cell, we first used the online analysis to map out the location and size of the cell’s receptive field center.

Ventral and dorsal root activity was recorded via suction electro

Ventral and dorsal root activity was recorded via suction electrodes (A-M Systems). Fluorescent dI3 INs were targeted on the basis of their location in the intermediate

spinal cord and recorded with care to not include cells that were deep (motoneurons). Most recordings were from L4 and L5 segments, but, when recording in rostral lumbar segments, neurons near the surface (possible autonomic motoneurons) were also avoided. Sensory fibers have different recruitment thresholds, which depend drug discovery on the size of the fiber and the degree of myelination (Erlanger and Gasser, 1930). To express stimulation strength, we defined T as either the lowest stimulus strength at which DR volleys or CDPs were first seen (if electrodes present) or the strength at which ventral root responses were seen. We classified the responses of dI3 INs as either low-threshold (1–2 T), which would include group I muscle afferents and low-threshold cutaneous afferents (Aβ) but also some group II and Aδ fibers, or high-threshold afferents (5–10 T), which putatively included group III and group IV muscle afferents and unmyelinated C fiber nociceptive afferents. Intermediate stimuli were classified as medium

threshold. T was typically between 4 and 20 μA in vitro. Adult mice were implanted with bipolar electromyography (EMG)-recording electrodes (Pearson et al., 2005; Akay et al., 2006) as well as cuff electrodes to stimulate the tibial and/or selleck screening library sural nerves. Following 1–3 weeks of recovery, nerves were stimulated with the use of single

or pairs of 250 μs pulses for the tibial nerve or with the use of trains of two Histone demethylase to five pulses for the sural nerve at frequencies of 500 Hz with an interval of 2 s between trains. Stimulation strengths used to attempt to elicit reflexes ranged between 75 and 500 μA (mean, 307 ± 135 μA; n = 11) in the control animals and 40 to 750 μA (mean, 248 ± 228 μA; n = 8) in the mutant animals (p = 0.31). In contrast, the nociceptive threshold (producing vocalizations) ranged between 300 and 1,500 μA (mean, 821 ± 356 μA; n = 7) in the control animals and between 250 and 900 μA (mean, 571 ± 216 μA; n = 7) in the mutant animals (p = 0.07). The differences between the stimulation used to elicit the short-latency reflexes and the threshold for vocalization were significant (paired t test, p < 0.05, n = 5 control and 2 dI3OFF animals). We implanted chronic epidural cord dorsum electrodes in four animals to determine stimulation thresholds (n = 2 mutant and 2 controls). The threshold to elicit short-latency cord dorsum responses from sural nerve stimulation was between 100 and 300 μA (Figure S5B; n = 2 mutants and 1 control); i.e., in the same range that we used to elicit reflex responses.

Careful histological analyses can address some of these concerns,

Careful histological analyses can address some of these concerns, with rigorous documentation of lesion extent and serial tracing of axons across different planes of sampling (Figure 5). Functional analyses are compromised unless thorough histological analyses are carried out on every animal to confirm lesion completeness. In all of these partial lesion models, strong, supportive evidence can Selleckchem Talazoparib mitigate concerns about sparing. If the axons take a course that is not seen in uninjured animals,

the claim for regeneration can be persuasive. For example, deletion of the tumor suppressor gene “phosphatase and tensin homolog” (PTEN) in mice after either dorsal hemisection or severe crush lesion results in bilateral extension of CST axons below the lesion that originate from a single hemisphere (Liu et al., 2010). Such bilateral projections are extremely rare in controls, and their

abundance in PTEN-deleted mice is supportive evidence for regeneration. Even when it can be established that axons have regrown past the lesion, it is usually not possible to conclude with certainty whether these axons originate from transected axons or from sprouts of spared CST axons that ordinarily terminate rostral to the injury. This requires complete reconstruction of the origin and course of the axons, which in turn requires sparse labeling. Many studies have assessed whether grafts or transplants can support CST growth. Implanted matrices have included Schwann cells, astrocytes, Dinaciclib neural stem cells, fibroblasts, oligodendrocyte precursor cells, bone marrow stromal cells, or other substances (Blesch and Tuszynski, 2009). While these matrices support the growth of other motor systems, including raphespinal, rubrospinal, and reticulospinal projections after injury, it is noteworthy that none of these matrices support CST axon growth. The only matrix

to date that supports CST growth is the grafting of fetal spinal cord (Coumans et al., 2001), and even then, growth is modest. Also, fetal spinal cord grafts are of limited practical usefulness because the grafted cells exhibit variable survival and rarely fill the lesion site (Coumans et al., 2001). A major unmet challenge in the field of spinal cord injury research remains first the identification of a substrate or matrix that will enable CST axon growth into a cystic lesion site. Although the CST has been relatively refractory to most therapeutic manipulations, other descending systems including raphespinal, cerulospinal, reticulospinal, rubrospinal, and propriospinal axons are somewhat more responsive (Blesch and Tuszynski, 2009). These systems mediate functions (locomotion, posture, balance, autonomic control) that would be important to comprehensively improve functional outcomes in people with SCI (Anderson et al., 2008).

, 2010) Thus, we hypothesized that DAF-21/Hsp90 and

EBAX

, 2010). Thus, we hypothesized that DAF-21/Hsp90 and

EBAX-1 may be involved in suppressing the level of endogenous aberrant misfolded proteins during axon guidance. Numerous human diseases have been associated with amino acid mutations, resulting in metastable proteins with temperature-sensitive (ts) misfolding defects (Gelsthorpe et al., 2008, Kjaer and Ibáñez, 2003, Pedersen et al., 2003, Singh et al., 1997 and Vollrath and Liu, 2006). One well-studied selleck inhibitor example is the ΔF508 mutant of cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator (CFTR) identified in cystic fibrosis patients (Lukacs and Verkman, 2012). The advance in therapeutic treatment of cystic fibrosis has heavily relied on PQC studies of the CFTR ΔF508 mutant. Being susceptible targets of the PQC system, such metastable mutant proteins can serve as sensitized probes to examine the function of PQC regulators. To identify in vivo targets of EBAX-1 and DAF-21, we searched for temperature-sensitive mutants with protein misfolding defects in the slt-1/sax-3 pathway. ISRIB order We found that a previously reported ts mutation of sax-3 (ky200) caused striking temperature-dependent misfolding and mislocalization of the SAX-3 receptor in touch neurons. sax-3(ky200) contains a missense mutation at a conserved proline residue (P37S) in the first immunoglobin-like domain (Ig1) ( Figure 5A) ( Zallen et al., 1998). In the vertebrate Robo1, this amino acid is close to

the contact regions between Slit2 and Robo1 but does not directly mediate their interaction ( Morlot et al., 2007). sax-3(ky200) mutant animals Sodium butyrate showed marginal penetrance of AVM guidance defects at the permissive temperature (20°C), suggesting that most mutant SAX-3 is functional under this condition. At the restrictive temperature (22.5°C), the level of defects significantly increased in sax-3(ky200) mutants ( Figure 5B). As a control, the guidance defects in sax-3(ky123) null mutants did not show temperature dependence. To test whether the temperature sensitivity of sax-3(ky200) mutants is caused by protein misfolding, we examined the expression patterns

of GFP-tagged SAX-3(WT) and SAX-3(P37S) in touch neurons. SAX-3(WT)::GFP and SAX-3(P37S)::GFP were expressed in the wild-type and sax-3(ky200) mutant backgrounds, respectively, to ensure the homogeneity of endogenous and exogenous proteins. In touch neurons at late L1 to early L2 stages, SAX-3(WT)::GFP was predominantly localized on the cell surface at both 20°C and 22.5°C ( Figure 5C). In contrast, SAX-3(P37S)::GFP showed a mixture of cell-surface and cytosolic localization with a mild degree of cytosolic aggregation at 20°C ( Figure 5C). The cytosolic mislocalization and aggregation of SAX-3(P37S)::GFP were exacerbated at 22.5°C and accompanied with a reduction of surface signals that correlated with the aggravated AVM guidance defects in sax-3(ky200) mutants ( Figures 5B and 5C).

This Ca2+ dependent

increase in the SV priming rate has b

This Ca2+ dependent

increase in the SV priming rate has been attributed to direct or indirect effects of increased [Ca2+]i on Munc13 activity, involving Ca2+-CaM binding, diacylglyerol binding, and Ca2+/phospholipid binding to regulatory domains of Munc13s (Betz et al., 2001; Dimova et al., 2006, 2009; Junge et al., 2004; Rhee et al., 2002; Shin et al., 2010). However, the corresponding evidence was exclusively obtained in cultured neurons. As a result, the question as to whether Munc13s are important determinants of Ca2+-dependent RRP replenishment and STP in native synapses within intact neuronal circuits has remained a focus of substantial controversy. By employing a KI mutant mouse line in which the WT protein is replaced by a Ca2+-CaM insensitive Munc13-1W464R variant and by using the calyx of Held as a model synapse, Cell Cycle inhibitor we demonstrate that Ca2+-CaM binding to Munc13-1 regulates RRP recovery from depletion and the time course of recovery from STD (Figures 3 and 7). These functional changes are a specific consequence

of blocked Ca2+-CaM binding to Munc13-1 (Figure 1G) because Munc13-1 expression (Figure 1F), its interaction with its key target protein Syntaxin 1 (Figure 1G), and its presynaptic localization (Figure 2), as well as the expression Autophagy inhibitor levels of Munc13-1 interactors and functionally related proteins (Figure S1) are not affected by the KI mutation. Our data show that Munc13-1 is an important Ca2+-CaM effector in the replenishment of the releasable SV pool in the calyx of

Held. The reduction of the replenishment rate of the fast releasing SV pool caused by the Munc13-1W464R mutation is similar in calyces before and after hearing onset (Figures 3 and 4), demonstrating that the SV release machinery depends upon the priming activity of Ca2+-CaM activated Munc13-1 throughout development. Strikingly, the effects of presynaptic introduction however of CaM inhibitors on RRP replenishment rates precisely mirror the effects of the Munc13-1W464R mutation, and the Munc13-1W464R mutation occludes any further effects of CaM inhibition (Figures 3D, 3E, 4D, and 4E). This indicates that the previously reported effects of CaM inhibition on RRP refilling in the calyx of Held (Sakaba and Neher, 2001) are mainly due to a perturbation of Ca2+-CaM-Munc13-1 signaling, and that Munc13-1 is a major presynaptic target of Ca2+-CaM-signaling in RRP replenishment. Ca2+-dependent acceleration of the replenishment rate of releasable SV pools is thought to contribute profoundly to the rapid recovery from synaptic depression after high-frequency AP trains and to determine the SSD level during the train (Neher and Sakaba, 2008; Wang and Kaczmarek, 1998). We report a significant retardation of the recovery of EPSCs after 300 Hz trains in P9–P11 calyces, and after 100 and 300 Hz trains in P14–P17 calyces of Munc13-1W464R mice (Figure 5), which likely reflects a reduction in Ca2+-dependent RRP recovery.

The resultant second-order component

The resultant second-order component selleck chemical is often denoted as “g.” This approach is particularly useful when tasks load heavily on multiple components, as it can simplify the task to first-order component weightings, making the factor solution more readily interpretable. A complication for this approach,

however, is that the underlying source of this second-order component is ambiguous. More specifically, while correlations between first-order components from the PCA may arise because the underlying factors are themselves correlated (for example, if the capacities of the MDwm and MDr networks were influenced by some diffuse factor like conductance speed or plasticity), they will also be correlated if there is “task mixing,” that is, if tasks tend to weigh on multiple independent factors. In behavioral factor analysis, these accounts are effectively indistinguishable as the components or latent variables cannot be measured directly. Here, we have an objective measure of the extent to which the tasks are mixed, as we know, based on the functional neuroimaging data, the extent to which the tasks recruit spatially separated functional networks

relative to rest. Consequently, it is possible to subdivide “g” into the proportion that is predicted by the mixing of tasks on multiple functional brain networks and the proportion click here that may be explained

by other diffuse factors (Figure 3). Two simulated data sets Tryptophan synthase were generated; one based on the loadings of the tasks on the MDwm and MDr functional networks (2F) and the other including task activation levels for the verbal network (3F). Each of the 44,600 simulated “individuals” was assigned a set of either two (2F) or three (3F) factor scores using a random Gaussian generator. Thus, the underlying factor scores represented normally distributed individual differences and were assumed to be completely independent in the simulations. The 12 task scores were assigned for each individual by multiplying the task-functional network loadings from the ICA of the neuroimaging data by the corresponding, randomly generated, factor score and summating the resultant values. The scores were then standardized for each task and noise was added by adding the product of randomly generated Gaussian noise, the test-retest reliabilities (Table S2), and a noise level constant. A series of iterative steps were then taken, in which the noise level constant was adjusted until the summed communalities from the simulated and behavioral PCA solutions were closely matched in order to ensure that the same total amount of variance was explained by the first-order components. This process was repeated 20 times to generate a standard deviation.

e , a research map; Figure 1C), and suggest causal hypotheses (Fi

e., a research map; Figure 1C), and suggest causal hypotheses (Figure 1D). Just as a GPS map affords different levels of zoom, someone reading a research map would be able to survey a specific

research area at different levels of resolution, from coarse summaries of findings (Figure 1C) to fine-grained accounts of experimental results. The primary function of a research map is to display no more and no less information to a user than is necessary for the researcher’s purposes. Primary research articles often contain summaries of prior research this website and statements concerning the significance of findings presented. Additionally, review articles can help to place specific collections of findings in a broader and more integrated perspective. However valuable they may be, the individual perspectives in research papers and review articles are not always objective and balanced. Frequently, they do not reflect all of the relevant information available for the topic being reviewed. Thus, in addition to these personal perspectives, it would be useful to consult exhaustive, inclusive, and integrated databases (i.e.,

research maps) concerning the results and experimental strategies of an area or topic of interest. To enhance the accessibility of research maps, each assertion would be stated in an unambiguous vocabulary. There are now numerous such vocabularies for automated reasoning, called ontologies (e.g., available through the National Center for Biomedical learn more Ontologies, or NCBO). Unlike natural languages (e.g., English), biomedical ontologies map one entity into one term. For instance, the word “nucleus” is ambiguous and could mean a cluster of cells, the nucleus of a single cell,

and an atomic nucleus. The different senses of “nucleus” receive different terms in biomedical ontologies, so that when data are annotated with one of these terms, there is no ambiguity to confound a search over that data and no ambiguity to confound automated reasoning. To date, the most extensive effort toward developing an ontology for neuroscience has been undertaken by the Neuroscience Information Framework (NIF). The NIF has collected a dynamic lexicon of over 19,000 neuroscience terms to describe neural structures and functions. The lexicon is built from the NIF standard ontologies (NIFSTD) not (Larson and Martone, 2009). To make these vocabularies available to nonspecialists, the NIF group has built a web app, NeuroLex, from which a user can easily find the right terms to describe a phenomenon or protocol. Ontologies like the NIFSTD provide materials for composing unambiguous representations of neuroscience research in a format sometimes called “nanopublication” (Groth et al., 2010). A nanopublication is the smallest unit of publishable information that can be uniquely identified and attributed to its author(s). Each of the eight experiments in Figure 1A could be reported in a single conventional research paper, or in eight nanopublications.

The BOLD undershoot in cat visual cortex occurred in both tissue

The BOLD undershoot in cat visual cortex occurred in both tissue and surface vessels. The CBV in gray matter, however, remained elevated after stimulus cessation, while CBV at the surface decayed rapidly to

baseline (Yacoub et al., 2006; Zhao et al., 2007); this was also observed in the macaque (data not shown). The above observations suggest the possibility that the poststimulus undershoot and the negative BOLD response may share a similar mechanism, resulting in a decrease of blood flow in the large vessels at the surface, while the parenchyma (the deeper layers) stays hyperemic. However, the temporal overlap makes PD-0332991 cost the individual contributions to the poststimulus undershoot difficult to disentangle, and vascular compliance effects can also explain the time course of the CBV (Buxton et al., 1998, 2004; Leite et al., 2002; Mandeville et al., 1999a, 1999b). Acquiring the time course of the CBF at laminar resolution could resolve the potential similarities between the negative BOLD and the poststimulus undershoot. Another stimulus paradigm that reliably yields negative BOLD responses is ipsilateral inhibition, and it is likely that this paradigm would result in similar laminar profiles to the ones found here. Although negative BOLD responses have also been shown in cases of physiological challenge, like seizures or low blood pressure (Nagaoka et al., 2006; Schridde et al., 2008),

its mechanism and laminar profiles might very well differ AZD2281 price from the stimulus-driven negative BOLD response. However, this requires further study. Decreases in the cerebral metabolic rate of oxygen consumption (CMRO2) were seen in areas with negative BOLD using MRI-based methods (Shmuel et al., 2002; Stefanovic et al., 2004). Although it is likely that the reduced neural activity (Shmuel et al., 2006) leads to a reduced energy use, this cannot automatically be inferred, and CMRO2 changes could also be layer dependent. Layer-dependent CMRO2 is suggested by observations that glucose and O2 consumption are highest in layer IV (Carroll and Wong-Riley, 1984; Li and Freeman, 2011, 2012; Tootell

et al., 1988b), while 2-deoxyglucose autoradiography in V1 showed that for areas adjacent crotamiton to stimulated areas, glucose use depended on stimulus properties and retinotopic location (Tootell et al., 1988b). The increase in CBV in the deeper layers might be driven by a cortical-layer-dependent increase in energy use, which could be the result of layer-dependent or neuron-type-dependent increases in neural activity. A possible driver of the microvascular dilation is an increase in the activity of inhibitory interneurons; these are often missed with standard microelectrodes, but they can have high firing rates. Inhibitory activity has been shown to cost energy (McCasland and Hibbard, 1997; Nudo and Masterton, 1986) and might lead to a vascular response also.

To study the contribution of the two CYFIP1 complexes on ARC synt

To study the contribution of the two CYFIP1 complexes on ARC synthesis

and actin cytoskeleton at synapses, primary cortical neurons (DIV9) were transfected selleck compound with scrambled or Cyfip1 (sh315) shRNA, in combination with CYFIP1 WT, mutant H (affecting actin polymerization), or mutant E (affecting mRNA translation). ARC and F-actin were detected by immunolabeling in neurons at DIV14 with or without BDNF treatment, and the immunosignal was quantified in spines outlined by the membrane-targeted farnesylated GFP (F-GFP) carried by the shRNA construct. We found that CYFIP1 downregulation caused augmented ARC synthesis and reduced F-actin levels in spines ( Figure 4B). Moreover, ARC and F-actin were enhanced after BDNF treatment, but not in Cyfip1-silenced neurons ( Figure 4B). Cotransfection SB431542 purchase of the construct carrying CYFIP1 WT rescued all defects, both basal and BDNF-induced. As predicted, basal and inducible ARC expression was restored by mutant H, but not by mutant E. F-actin levels, in contrast, were rescued by mutant E, but not by mutant H. The fact that mutant E rescued F-actin expression but remains insensitive to BDNF stimulation ( Figure 4B) might

suggest that this pathway requires local translation in addition to WRC activation. In conclusion, the data demonstrate that the CYFIP1 mutants are valuable in separating the two functions found of CYFIP1 in the regulation of local protein translation and the control of actin cytoskeleton at synapses. Alterations in factors controlling protein synthesis (e.g., FMRP) or actin remodeling (e.g., WAVE1) cause dendritic spine defects (Irwin et al., 2001 and Kim et al., 2006). Therefore, we addressed the question of whether CYFIP1 plays a role in dendritic spine formation by studying mice deficient in Cyfip1. Brain slices were isolated from Cyfip1+/– and WT littermates, and individual neurons were labeled diolistically. Dendritic

spines were measured and assigned to four morphological classes, namely mature (stubby and mushroom) and immature types (long thin and filopodia). Neurons displayed a spine distribution in agreement with previous ex vivo studies ( Galvez and Greenough, 2005 and Irwin et al., 2002). Neurons from Cyfip1+/– mice, despite the mild reduction in CYFIP1, showed an increased population of filopodia ( Figures 5A–5C), but no defects in spine density and head width (data not shown). To reduce CYFIP1 expression more drastically, primary cortical neurons (DIV9) were silenced for Cyfip1 (sh319 and sh315, or scrambled shRNA), and spine density and morphology were examined at DIV14. Neuronal morphology was outlined by a farnesylated GFP (F-GFP) carried by the shRNA construct ( Figures 5A–5D and S5E). Spines were classified as above.