With all markers integrated, 10 phyla/subphyla, 19 classes, 64 orders, and 205 genera were detected in this study (Fig. 2, Table 3). Table 3 Summary of taxonomic assignations and species diversity using six markers Assignation ITS1/2 ITS3/4 nrLSU-LR nrLSU-U mtLSU mtATP6 Fungal reads 1,294,385 513,844 385,278 6,018,234 5,670,611 2,171,475 Assigned to phylum level 1,285,639 504,494 322,245 6,012,781 5,867,195 2,171,471 Assigned to order level 967,973 130,424 319,267 4,267,361 5,618,342 2,170,485 Assigned to genus level 871,208 73,730 283,860 4,025,934 5,616,600 2,170,410 Fungal OTUs 512 364 288 1,189 387 60 Assigned to phylum level 492 345 252 1,163 376 58 Assigned to class level
405 248 208 943 339 57 Assigned to order level 381 224 159 822 319 50 Assigned to genus level 260 132 112 487 260 43 Phylum/subphylum Ascomycota 354 257 #BI 2536 solubility dmso randurls[1|1|,|CHEM1|]# 123 883
328 2 Basidiomycota 130 74 117 267 48 56 Chytridiomycota 2 4 2 Entomophthoromycota 2 2 Glomeromycota 2 Neocallimastigomycota 1 Kickxellomycotina 1 Mortierellomycotina 7 3 3 6 Mucoromycotina 1 4 2 5 Identified orders (Total 64) 34 31 35 46 19 6 Identified genera (Total 201) 76 38 32 111 33 8 Fig. 1 Read distribution of sequences according to phylum (a) and class EX527 (b) of fungi in roots of greenhouse-grown Phalaenopsis KC1111. Bar colors denote the taxon detected by each marker Fig. 2 Hierarchical tree representing taxonomic relationships of fungal genera detected in roots of greenhouse-grown Phalaenopsis. Branch colors indicate the classes (in boxes) of the OTUs. The height of the bars in the circle outside the Interleukin-2 receptor branch tips corresponds to the number of OTUs within genera. The key to bar color for the markers is at the top right Multiple
rarefactions and alpha-diversity estimations As the total numbers of sequences varied across the six markers, from the lowest of 385, 278 with ITS3/4 to the highest of 6,018,234 with nrLSU-LR, multiple rarefactions were performed on markers to minimize the bias resulting from unequal sequencing depths. ITS1/2, ITS3/4, and nrLSU-U showed similar resolutions at low sequencing depths, as indicated by the curves of these markers that overlapped when the rarefied number was less than 100,000 (Fig. 3). Nevertheless, as the number of sequences increased, nrLSU-U demonstrated the best resolution (442.4 OTUs of 385,000 sequences) compared with other markers, followed by ITS1/2 (371.4 OTUs) and ITS3/4 (333.8 OTUs). We further estimated the alpha diversity of the fungal community with the rarefied data set. The two alpha diversity indicators, Shannon’s and Gini-Simpson’s indices, were adopted due to their stability and robustness in metagenomic analyses (Haegeman et al. 2013). Table 4 shows the rarefied Shannon’s and Gini-Simpson’s indices for floras uncovered by markers, in which ITS1/2 (2.49 and 0.85 for Shannon’s and Gini-Simpson’s indices, respectively) displayed higher specie richness than ITS3/4 (2.02 and 0.